Guide · Businesses · 3 min read · Updated 17 November 2026
Fob vs Keypad vs Mobile vs Biometric Access Control
Short answer
Keypads are cheapest but codes are easily shared. Fobs and cards are the everyday standard, easy to issue and cancel, but can be lost or, in older formats, copied. Mobile credentials use staff smartphones and are managed remotely. Biometric readers tie access to a person but process special category data under UK GDPR. Many sites combine fobs or mobile with a keypad for higher-security doors.
How the main credential types compare
The credential is what a person presents at the door to prove they are allowed in. It is the part of the system users notice most, and it drives day-to-day management: issuing access to new starters, removing leavers and dealing with lost items. Each type has strengths and weaknesses, and the right choice depends on how many users you have, how often they change and how sensitive the area is.
| Credential | Security | Convenience | Main drawback |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keypad code | Low to moderate | Nothing to carry | Codes shared or overlooked |
| Proximity fob or card | Moderate | Quick tap | Lost items; older formats can be copied |
| Encrypted smart card or fob | Good | Quick tap | Higher cost per credential |
| Mobile credential | Good | Uses phone already carried | Phone battery, subscription costs |
| Biometric | High | Nothing to carry | UK GDPR special category data |
Keypads
Keypads let people in with a numeric code. They are inexpensive, need no credentials to issue and work well for low-risk doors such as staff kitchens, bin stores or a side gate. Standalone keypads hold codes in the unit itself, so no software is needed.
The weakness is that a code identifies a group, not a person. Codes are shared, written down, overlooked or passed to former staff, and changing them means telling everyone. Worn keys on the keypad can also give away which digits are used. On networked systems, a keypad can be combined with a fob for two-factor entry on sensitive doors, which is far more secure than either alone.
If you keep a keypad, change the code on a regular schedule and whenever someone with the code leaves.
Fobs and cards
Fobs and cards are the most common credential in UK offices, schools and residential blocks. A reader detects the credential at close range and the controller checks whether that user is allowed through that door at that time. When someone leaves or loses a fob, it is cancelled in the software without changing locks.
Not all fobs are equal. Older low-frequency proximity credentials can be cloned with cheap devices, which is a known weakness. Modern encrypted smart credentials make copying much harder. If you are installing a new system or upgrading readers, ask what credential technology is used and whether it is encrypted.
- Cancel lost fobs immediately in the software
- Ask whether credentials are encrypted or legacy proximity
- Issue visitor or contractor fobs with expiry times
- Keep a register of who holds which fob
- Combine with a PIN for server rooms and stockrooms
Mobile credentials
Mobile access turns a smartphone into the credential, usually through an app using Bluetooth or NFC. Administrators can issue or revoke access remotely in seconds, which suits businesses with several sites, flexible workspaces, and residential buildings where tenants change often. Many people already carry their phone everywhere, so there is less to lose and nothing to post out.
Considerations include phone battery life, staff who do not want work apps on personal phones, and per-user subscription fees on many cloud platforms. Most sites keep a few fobs or cards as backup for those situations.
Check that the readers you install can accept mobile credentials, even if you start with fobs. Switching later then only needs a software change rather than new hardware at every door.
Biometric readers
Biometric readers recognise a fingerprint, face or other physical characteristic. They remove the problem of lost or shared credentials, because access is tied to the person. They are used for high-security rooms, laboratories, data centres and some time-and-attendance systems.
Biometric data used to identify people is special category data under UK GDPR, which means stricter conditions apply. Organisations need a lawful basis and an additional condition for processing, should complete a data protection impact assessment, and should usually offer an alternative to staff who do not wish to use biometrics. Readers also need careful placement and good lighting to work reliably.
Choosing a combination
Most sites benefit from mixing credential types by door. A typical setup uses fobs or mobile credentials on main entrances, a keypad on low-risk internal doors, and fob plus PIN or biometrics on server rooms or stock areas. Readers that accept more than one credential type make this easier and allow a gradual move from fobs to mobile.
Think about the people as well as the technology. A system that is awkward to use gets propped open, which defeats the purpose. Clear processes for new starters, leavers, lost credentials and visitors matter as much as the reader on the wall.
Questions to ask an installer
Ask which credential technology the readers support, whether credentials are encrypted, and whether the readers can accept mobile credentials later without replacement. Ask how users are added and removed, whether the software keeps an audit log, and how long logs are retained. For biometrics, ask how templates are stored and secured and what support is offered for data protection compliance. Finally, ask about the cost of extra credentials and any subscription per user or per door, so you can compare options on a like-for-like basis.
Questions people also ask
Can access control fobs be copied?
Some can. Older low-frequency proximity fobs and cards can be cloned with inexpensive devices. Modern encrypted smart credentials are much harder to copy. If your system uses older fobs, upgrading readers and credentials is a sensible security step, and it often reuses existing locks and cabling.
Is biometric access control legal in the UK?
Yes, but biometric data used to identify people is special category data under UK GDPR. You need a lawful basis and an additional condition, should carry out a data protection impact assessment, keep data secure and usually offer an alternative method. ICO guidance explains these duties.
What happens if staff lose their phone with mobile access?
An administrator revokes the mobile credential remotely, usually in seconds, and reissues it to the new phone. Most systems also keep fobs or cards available as backup. Phone security such as screen locks adds protection, as the credential app typically requires the phone to be unlocked.
Written and checked by the Access Control Installation team. Read our editorial policy.
More guides
How Much Does an Access Control System Cost in the UK?
A standalone keypad or reader on one door typically costs £450–£900 fitted in the UK. Networked fob or card access usually runs £900–£1,800 per door,…
Access Control Rules in the UK: Fire Safety and GDPR Explained
Access control must never stop people escaping in a fire. Doors on escape routes need a reliable way to open without a key, such as push bars, exit…
Door Entry Systems for Flats: A Guide for Landlords and Managers
A door entry system for flats links a panel at the main entrance to a handset, video screen or app in each flat, so residents can see or speak to…
How to Choose an Access Control Installer: What to Check
Choose an access control installer who surveys every door, understands fire exits and fire alarm integration, specifies locks that suit each door,…
Get a free access control installation quote
Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a clear price.
Request a quote